Designated Survivor Do-over - Designated Survivor

August 2024 · 3 minute read

3 hours ago, Danielg342 said:

I'm going to add to this.

First, I like the storylines @Pindrop has come up with, so I'm not going to offer an alternative. It's essentially the same track that I would take.

I'll make a note for what I think the characters should be like, since that was not addressed:

Yes, Kirkman needed some major changes, at least the version of him that existed after his learning-the-ropes arc was over in the first third of the first season. I cannot understand how experienced writers (I assume, but judging by how amateurish a lot of the writing was, perhaps not) still have a Mary-Sue (or, more accurately, several Mary-Sues) at the centre of the show.

There are multiple problems with a Mary-Sue; they are unrelatable, they are unbelievable, and they are unlikeable, but worst of all they remove all of the following from the writer’s toolkit; any conflict (other than superficial and juvenile black/white) with other characters; any threat/stakes provided by the possibility of failure; any character arcs through learning from experiences/ mistakes; any overriding narrative thrust that is about anything other than propping up the Mary-Sue’s awesomeness.

The main problem with this show was that Kirkman (the version of him beyond the first third of season 1, that is) was such an insufferable prick.

Edited May 23, 2018 by Pindrop

ncG1vNJzZmien6fCrr%2BNqamipZWptq6x0WeaqKVfqbyxtcJobmlqZGd6pbHSop6nmaSasW6%2F1Kutoq6fp3qlu4yorZ6qXw%3D%3D